A deductive analysis of the conciliar decree in relation to Pope Pius IX’s Quanta Cura, and whether the opposition is merely apparent, or real…
Introduction
Some readers, perhaps, may bristle at the question in the title, even going so far as to dismiss it. If this is your inclination, we encourage you to keep reading. Agree or disagree, what follows is among the most potent arguments for rupture between Catholic tradition and the conciliar teaching. Assuming, arguendo, continuity could be proved, importantly according to sound methodology, the following argument of rupture would need to be sufficiently answered. In any case, the author of this critical analysis is Fr. Hervé Belmont. With his gracious permission, we are happy to present his arguments in English, where they will hopefully reach a wide Catholic audience. A sincere and intellectually curious audience, that desires to pursue and embrace Truth above all else, whatever the consequences.
Continue Reading
https://substack.com/home/post/p-163401158
