The Jewish Talmud names four legal categories beyond male and female — six in all. Does ancient Jewish law really endorse gender fluidity? We examine the sources, the Orthodox Jewish rebuttal the internet leaves out, what the Church teaches on the two sexes, and the source of modern transgenderism.
⏱️ TIMESTAMPS
0:00 – Cold Open
0:05 – INTRODUCTION
1:38 – PART 1: What the Rabbis Actually Said
6:08 – PART 2: Scripture Reading — Genesis 1:27 (Douay-Rheims)
7:04 – PART 3: The Modern Retcon
9:34 – PART 4: Judaism’s Own Rebuttal
12:04 – PART 5: What the Church Actually Teaches
15:24 – PART 6: Where the Modern Idea Actually Comes From
19:06 – CONCLUSION
📖 SOURCES FOR THIS VIDEO
Scripture
Genesis 1:27 — Douay-Rheims
Matthew 19:4 — Douay-Rheims
Deuteronomy 22:5 — Douay-Rheims
Deuteronomy 23:1 — Douay-Rheims
Rabbinic / Talmudic
Mishnah Bikkurim 4:1–5 — androginos legal status, including the “unique creature” statement, now attributed to Rabbi Yose
Bikkurim 2:6 and Bavli Yevamot 83a as parallel attestations, and an independent search of mine turned up a Grokipedia entry corroborating the Yevamot 83a location. Citation now reads Bikkurim 4:5 with the Yevamot 83a parallel noted on screen.
Mishnah Yevamot 8:5–6 — saris and aylonit exempted from chalitzah/levirate marriage
Mishnah Nazir 2:7
Modern Jewish (Progressive)
Rabbi Elliot Kukla, “Ancient Judaism Recognized a Range of Genders. It’s Time We Did, Too.” — The New York Times, March 18, 2023
Elliot Kukla, “A Created Being of Its Own” — Master’s Thesis, Hebrew Union College, 2006 (Trans Torah project origin)
“The Eight Genders in the Talmud” — My Jewish Learning (source of the “rabbis did not use the word gender as we do today” concession)
Modern Jewish (Orthodox Response)
Jason Bedrick (Heritage Foundation), response to the Kukla NYT essay, March 2023
JNS, “‘New York Times’ Article Claiming Ancient Judaism Recognized ‘a Range Of Genders’ Draws Criticism,” March 2023
Magisterial / Catholic
St. Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae I, q. 76, a. 1 (soul as substantial form of the body); I, q. 92, a. 1 (woman in the first production of things); Supplement, q. 81, a. 3 (both sexes rise in the resurrection)
Congregation for Catholic Education, Male and Female He Created Them, June 10, 2019
Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith, Dignitas Infinita, n. 60, April 8, 2024, approved by Pope Francis
Modern Clinical History (Part 6)
Magnus Hirschfeld — coined “transvestite,” 1910 (Die Transvestiten); founded the Institute for Sexual Science, Berlin, 1919; “sexual intermediaries” theory (43,046,721 combinations); institute destroyed by the Nazis in 1933, died in exile 1935
Harry Benjamin — German-American endocrinologist; treated Christine Jorgensen (1952 case); The Transsexual Phenomenon, 1966, a landmark medical monograph (not, as an earlier draft implied, the origin of the word itself — Hirschfeld used “transsexualism” in 1923); still called “the father of transsexualism” in the medical literature itself (e.g., a Wiley reference-work entry uses that exact phrase)
John Money, “gender role,” 1955, Johns Hopkins
Robert Stoller, “gender identity,” 1964, UCLA
Richard Green — wrote the appendix/bibliography for Benjamin’s 1966 book; co-edited Transsexualism and Sex Reassignment with Money (1969); co-authored clinical papers with Stoller (1972); founded the International Academy of Sex Research (1975) and was a founding committee member of the Harry Benjamin International Gender Dysphoria Association (1979, precursor to WPATH)
📚 Full Adversus Judaeos Library: https://christtheking.info/catholic-r…
⚠️ DISCLAIMER: This video presents historical theological sources for educational purposes. The teaching documented is theological/doctrinal opposition, not racial hatred. Individual Jews can convert and be saved. Violence against Jews is condemned.
