Can a Protestant ask God for a sign—and receive an answer through his own daughter? In this remarkable clip, Sam Shamoun reacts to a Reformed Protestant who began studying the Catholic and ancient Christian teachings about Mary, including Mary’s perpetual virginity, purity, veneration, and the Assumption of Mary.
The Protestant explains that studying the original Reformers challenged many of his assumptions. Martin Luther, John Calvin, Ulrich Zwingli, and other early Protestant Reformers held a much higher view of the Virgin Mary than many modern Evangelicals and non-denominational Christians. This led him to reconsider whether Protestants had moved too far away from their own historical roots.
Although he remained committed to sola Scriptura, sola fide, Reformed theology, and the rejection of papal authority, the evidence surrounding Catholic miracles, Marian apparitions, Eucharistic miracles, Our Lady of Zeitoun, Our Lady of Fatima, and the intercession of Saint Charbel began challenging his worldview. Sam Shamoun explains why this internal struggle resembles his own journey away from Calvinism and toward the ancient apostolic churches.
The central moment occurs when the Protestant studies the Assumption of Mary and concludes that he cannot find enough biblical or early Christian evidence to accept it. He then asks God directly to reveal the truth if Mary was truly assumed into heaven. The following morning, without knowing anything about her father’s prayer or research, his six-year-old daughter tells him that she dreamed she saw Mary going up into heaven.
Sam Shamoun reacts to this astonishing testimony and explains the important distinction between the Ascension of Jesus Christ and the Assumption of Mary. Jesus Christ ascended into heaven through His own divine authority as God incarnate, while Mary’s Assumption means that she was taken into heaven by the power of God.
Sam Shamoun argues that the child’s dream was especially significant because she knew nothing about her father’s prayer, his study of Mariology, or the doctrine of Mary’s Assumption. According to Sam Shamoun, God answered the Protestant’s prayer through his innocent daughter so that he could not dismiss the experience as his own imagination or subconscious thoughts.
The conversation ultimately raises deeper questions about Protestantism, Catholicism, the ancient Christian tradition, Marian doctrines, miracles, dreams, visions, and whether God still gives signs that lead Christians toward the fullness of the apostolic faith.
⏱️ Timestamps
0:00 Sam Shamoun introduces the Protestant’s testimony
1:03 His Reformed worldview begins to collapse
2:24 The Protestant’s integrity and research into miracles
4:46 Studying Mary and the beliefs of the Reformers
6:49 What is the Assumption of Mary?
7:55 Why he believed the Bible was silent about the Assumption
8:35 He asks God to reveal whether the Assumption is true
9:16 His six-year-old daughter sees Mary going into heaven
10:25 Why the daughter’s dream shocked him
11:17 Sam Shamoun explains why God answered through the child
12:16 Miracles, visions, and the evidence for ancient Christianity
⚠️ Important Disclaimer
I am not Sam Shamoun. This channel edits and shares clips from his teachings with permission in order to make his content more accessible and help spread the Word of God. All credit for the teaching belongs to Sam Shamoun.
