Three years in, Fr. Carlos Martins does something the show has never done: he puts his producer and co-host on the stand and interviews Ryan about his journey and how the show has impacted him.
Timestamps
00:00 Cold Open: The Fraud, the Bias, and the Mess
00:59 Fr. Martins Puts Ryan on the Spot
01:17 I Thought You Were a Fraud
03:32 What He Believed Before Any of This
05:15 The Exorcist Stereotype, and the Men He Met
07:57 Sixty Percent Is Sometimes Enough
08:30 Name Three Things You Have Learned
12:06 SPONSOR BREAK: BUBS Naturals, Rocket Money
15:00 What Surprised Him Most About Catholicism
17:44 Statues, Altars, and Stones of Remembrance
18:18 The Convergence Nobody Expected
19:43 Drama or Catechesis: Where the Line Sits
22:41 The Dad Joke Dispensation
24:31 Favorite Case, Best Case, Most Hated Case
28:12 Someone Offered to Pay for the Answer
28:30 SPONSOR BREAK: Miracle Made, Exodus 90
31:44 Why Gary Will Not Be Spoken Of
32:50 The Case That Got Under His Skin
35:19 Clergy Complaints and Parents Using It as a Lesson
36:30 A Playground for Many Men
38:35 Sex as a Delivery Mechanism
39:34 The Biggest Misconception About Evil
41:44 You Are a Bad Judge of What You Would Do
42:36 The Episode That Vanished, and the Detroit Blackout
43:39 Can a Christian Be Possessed?
45:55 What He Would Say to a Skeptic
48:34 Show Me the Video Means Less Every Year
48:57 Is It Really That Crazy?
51:26 Would a Million Dollars a Month Buy an Episode a Day?
54:19 Thirty Hours of Post for One Hour of Show
55:52 The Email That Made It Worth It
59:56 How Three Years Changed His Walk With God
01:01:33 A Beautiful Theological Mess
01:05:26 Sign-Off
